6

My Thoughts on Santa

by Beav on December 7, 2009

This is going to be a rare post in which I’m not sure where I’m going to end up by the end.  But this post is going to focus on Santa.  It’s about that time where various Christians will start posting stuff on why Jesus is superior to Santa.  My friend told me he got a gift a few Christmas’s back which was an ornament in which Santa is portrayed as bowing to a baby Jesus in a manger. That’s hysterical to me.As an aside a co-worker of mine once joked that he could make a living playing off of this kind of religious reactivity – you know like build a company that does stuff like the Christian fish on the cars.  He said he could think of a dozens of things like the fish on the car which is countered by the Darwin fish with feet which is countered by a bigger Christian fish eating the Darwin fish.  He suggested that you could do Calvin from Calvin and Hobbes peeing on either fish or a host of other decals that try to stick it to the other.  From a marketing standpoint it’s shrewd because you can make a bunch of money just by generating reactivity and then marketing to it.  The Santa vs. Jesus arena has potential there as well.Anyway, I like Santa.  I like Christmas.  I like the spiritual side of it.  I confess I even like some of the materialistic side of it from black friday to day after Christmas sales even though I rarely buy anything extra.  I like the Santa Claus mythology and all the cartoon shows.While some may go to great lengths to do their own version of peeing on Santa in various ways to prove the superiority of Christianity or the superiority of Jesus, I think Santa opens up a door to an aspect of Jesus that sometimes gets overshadowed in the Scriptures  – how counter cultural Jesus was in relating to children in his day.    Children were at the low end of the totem pole in terms of status in the ancient world, a far cry from our children focused society in the western world today.  Those episodes of the disciples keeping children away from Jesus and Jesus counter culturally giving children incredible access and dignity. You’ll no doubt hear a sermon this month that focuses on how we should have childlike faith with an emphasis on innocence and purity of heart.  However, I find the real amazing thing about Jesus is that children have access because Jesus sees them as important to his plan too.It was radical and I see in Santa a tribute of sorts to that aspect of Jesus.  Santa is a symbol of approachability and someone who is a hero and in some ways an advocate for children.  That’s the lore behind St. Nicholas as well.  Of course today the mythology has taken on some of the image of the current culture, but there are aspects of St. Nick that remain and now having kids of my own I see the awe and naive enthusiasm that they have for figures that are larger than life and that show them significant value and dignity.So I will not be slamming Santa anytime soon nor will I be allowing Christian fish decals swallow him whole nor will I be having Calvin urinate on him on my back window.  While I do believe Jesus is superior and it’s a no contest situation between Jesus and Santa, there are great things about the Santa tradition that I fully support even if I do happen to have my own reasons for them.  I don’t expect people to share my own perspectives on this.  People have some good reasons for taking various stands. To some Santa is a complete embodiment of all things materialism.  I can see some of that.  But there’s some things in the mythology that obviously connect to the human heart because the Santa Claus movement has grown over time to cover some serious ground and influence most of the world in various forms.  So I can get with and celebrate Santa (in moderation) though I do find it incomparable with the experience of celebrating the incarnation.So I’ve reached the end.  If that ended up halfway coherent I’ll be pleased, but those are some of the Santa – Jesus thoughts I’ve had this Christmas season thus far.Have you had any?

Print Friendly
This work, unless otherwise expressly stated, is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.
  • Jim O'Connor

    Part 1 of 2 CommentsThis is an incredibly thoughtful, as well as timely, posting. I especially liked your thoughts on the countercultural aspects of Jesus' treatment of children.As the father of five, I lived the tension between the secular and the sacred at Christmas time. In our family, we tried to strike a balance, as your posting suggests. As parents, we tried to complete our shopping before the start of Advent so that as parents we could focus on the spiritual aspect of Christmas. We also NEVER lied to our kids, so we always presented the idea of Santa as a legend, which preserved our integrity and let them be kids.

  • Jim O'Connor

    Part 2 of 2 CommentsWe also picked names out of a hat on the first Sunday of Advent and we had to secretly do at least one nice thing a day for the person whose name you drew each day, and then give that person a small, non-anonymous gift at Christmas, thus revealing who had who's name. They really got into the spirit of the thing. We also attended the appropriate church services throughout the four weeks prior to Christmas, and did other religious/spiritual things at home. But we also went to the mall, saw Santa, etc. I honestly believe there are potential negatives to the no-Santa approach. After all, our kids are going to have to live in a world in tension with the Gospel, and as parents we have to model a way to do that, not just at Christmas but through out the year. We did our best, in all things, to model the behavior we expected from them. For me, doing my level best to live out the teachings of Jesus day in and day out makes a lot more sense than "killing Santa" once a year.This is, for me, one of your very best postings. Many thanks.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/BVirtue Beav

      fun to hear your thoughts Jim, sounds like a great way to approach things. That's helpful as we try to establish our own traditions as a family. thanks!

  • carrie

    interesting, beav, i never thought of it in this way before. thanks for your thoughts!and jim, i love the idea of drawing names during advent and doing special things for them in secret, that's so fun!

  • http://www.brianbarela.typepad.com Brian Barela

    i'm late on chiming in but it's 11:30 in ohio and i'm trying to make myself tired by reading blogs :) i'm all about santa–he provides kids with a sense of mystery and awe, and unlike Jesus (please don't let me get hit by lightening) he can actually be touched–my son just sat on his lap tonight–it was awesome and almost made me cry.the prophetic side of me wants to say something about the dark side of christian parenting and how it strives to reduce & control mystery and wonder and use God to alleviate their fear of the unknown–but i won't :) thanks for letting me ramble!

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/BVirtue Beav

      I agree about the wonder and mystery factor. The biggest obstacle to wonder and mystery is fear…which leads to control…which leads to the dark side…which leads to hate…(or something like that).I was confirmed in some of this too when my kids had a santa encounter as well. I could tell Morgan had tons going on inside of her even though she was a bit nervous. Colin was still a bit suspicious but he was a bit in awe as well. Fun stuff.

Previous post:

Next post: